Are Americans better off than the Dutch?

For a lot of questions, comparisons of per-capita GDP yield the correct answer to a first-order of approximation. For example, are Americans richer than the Chinese?  A comparison of GDPs per capita, adjusted for PPP differences, yields an unambiguous answer in favor of the U.S.  Yes, income may be distributed more unequally in the U.S., but that is largely irrelevant. As the chart below shows, very few Chinese are richer than the poorest Americans.  The distributions of income for the two countries barely overlap.   

(Note these data are for 2005. The Chinese distribution has caught up some with the U.S. one in the meantime.)

But what about the following question: Are Americans richer than the Dutch?  The average income in the U.S. is about 20 percent higher in the U.S. (again, adjusting for cost-of-living differences). So our inclination may be to answer in the affirmative.  But when average incomes do not differ by a large margin, income distributions do matter a lot. It turns out that the answer to the question depends very much on where in the income distribution we look at.

The following chart shows the average incomes of different income groups in the two countries. In each country, population is split into 20 equally-sized groups (“ventiles”), ranked from the poorest to the richest.

The two distributions cross, roughly at the middle.  The bottom 40% or so of the population is better off in the Netherlands, especially as we go lower in the distribution of income.  The bottom 5% have nearly double the income in the Netherlands.  The top 50%, by contrast, are significantly better off in the U.S.

So are the Americans better off than the Dutch? I cannot tell you.  But I can say that per-capita GDP or aggregate productivity numbers cannot answer the question.

By the way, these data on income distribution come via Branko Milanovic.  Check his book and web page.

And if you want to have more fun comparing income distributions across and within countries, check this puzzle.  (The answer is here).

Comments

[Michallehuta450]

Why not the same "bell curves chart" for the second comparison?

[Andreasmoser.wordpress.com]

Americans will definitely be better off than the Dutch once global warming will have risen the sea levels so much that Holland will have disappeared.
Ironically, this will be caused by Americans more than by the Dutch. Unfair.

[Niels Rademaker]

Misschien een betere basis voor het vergelijken van welzijn, productiviteit per uur gewerkt: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_hour_worked

Als je twee keer zo veel verdient maar er drie keer zo lang voor moet werken ben je natuurlijk niet wezenlijk "rijker".

Wat ik wel vaak frappant vind is that we de neiging hebben kleine landjes als Nederland te vergelijken met continent bedekkende titanen als de VS. Dan kun je beter staten met Europese landen vergelijken. Ik denk dat dan blijkt dat we nog aardig wat om jaloers op te zijn hebben (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_GDP).

[Niels Rademaker]

Sorry, I mistook this for a blog in Dutch; here is the translation of my post:

Perhaps a better basis for comparing wellbeing, productivity per hour worked: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_hour_worked

When you make twice as much but have to work for it three times as long, obviously you are not in a material way "richer".

What I do find curious is that there is a tendency to compare countries like the Netherlands to massive, continent spanning titans like the US. It makes more sense to compare states to countries as small as the Netherlands so that at least the population and geographical area are comparable. It seems to me there is quite a bit for the Dutch to be jealous of when viewed in this light: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_GDP

[Worstall]

I would very much want to see the details of the incomes in that second chart.

For the US has a strange way, internationally, of measuring the income of the poor. It is, by and large, solely market income (in more detail, market income plus direct cash transfers. But it excludes all transfers in kind and through the tax system. This matters because the majority of US poverty alleviation is done through transfers in kind and the tax system.)

The Dutch system (and pretty much everywhere else) measures poverty and the incomes of the poor after transfers.

So it does rather depend upon what Milanovic has done there. He may have corrected the US figure (I hope he has) so that we are indeed looking at post tax, post benefits incomes.

Or, if he hasn't so corrected then we're looking at US numbers before poverty alleviation and redistribution of incomes and Dutch numbers post.

I'd very much like to know which numbers he's using. Precisely where does this information come from?

[Account Deleted]

this is really interesting as well looking like china is betting usa... but we can see that usa is been trying to come out after that recession & still not that much healthy then before.

so now the next session data would be interesting to see. USA is very much giving fighting.. i don't think so just one or two session can be that much effective...

by HKkundariya
web design company

[Kaveh Majlesi]

Another thing that should be taken into consideration is that, given a specific set of skills one owns or how much one works, where she would be placed in the two distributions. If person A could be placed in top 5 percent in Holland working 8 hours a day, it is not clear she would be in the same category in the United States. This makes the comparison between groups across the two countries more complicated, I believe.

[Rgiordan]

An illustrative propaganda piece would be descriptive profiles of a representative person from each decile of the income distribution.

[D]

Thanks for the great piece of sharing. Enjoy to read your write. Awesome journal. Thank you for putting into words what I have been feeling.
you can take a look my online store Adidas Porsche Design

[terryj]

Well, of course they are. The thing is, in America there are severe gaps between various social groups.

[AlexCamp43]

wow, i can't say i am not surprised.
i thought things are worse with China
(my site:checkers game)

[Account Deleted]

Useful information shared..I am very happy to read this post..Thanks for giving us nice information.I appreciate this post.

15c2-11

[Dbyoyokaa]

So professional post which make me learn a lot! Really appreciate! chnlove scam

[Body Jewelry]

The wholesale Body Jewelry market with cubic zirconia includes diverse collections of earrings, pendants and rings,http://www.sirsee.com in designs that are sure to please your customers most extravagant desire.

[Ilir Deebran]

You can never understand these issues without using the utility scale created by Alex Gheg. Quantity, quality, variety and convenience in one equation. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u6tFLGpcOpE

[Account Deleted]

Nice article, thanks for the information.
Anna @ sewa mobil jakarta

[Account Deleted]

Are you better off than you were four years ago? It's a harder question than you might think.

Don,
http://yesshop.yolasite.com/blog.php

[Thegatruf]

I do agree that per-capita GDP can not help in answering such question. I don't know much about the Netherlands. Would be interesting to look at countries in the Scandinavia, more especially at the time when many Americans despise welfare economic models. One thing I am sure about though is that very few Americans are richer that the poorest Norwegians. You don't even need to look at the GDP weird statistical graphs. You only need to go to Norway an witness for yourself.

[Lglgluada Guada]

I don’t suppose I have read anything like this before. Extremely impressed with the excellence of the knowledge offered. I sincerely hope that you keep up with the good job conducted..
The Essay Writing

[Maximumask Erotik]

seks shop mağzamız diğer erotik shop mağzalarından farklı olarak gerçek ve orjinal sex shop ürünleri satmaktadır yerimiz istanbul kadıköy boğa heykelinin karşısındadır.
satığımız ürünler şişme mankenler vibratör geciktirici sprey ve daha bir çok ürün çeşidimiz ile seks shop hizmetinizde

[Mark Anthony]

I surmise I have chosen an intelligent and mind blowing website with interesting material.
http://www.whiteflash.com/about-diamonds/diamond-education/diamond-clarity.htm

[Alice]

I'd like to read more from you,expecting your new articles. you can take a look my website: http://www.dailydeal-shoes.com, Porsche Design Adidas

[rajesh]

I am really surprised to see that the per capita income of the china is more than that of USA. USA is also growing day by day and I hope USA will beat the china for Per capita incomde in next coming years.

by Rajesh Kanjani
web design San Diego

[Bestweddingideas.wordpress.com]

Fine, don't forget though that the Dutch will never surpass Americans in terms of cultural impact over the world. And sometimes this is way more important, as you can go literally to every spot under the Sun and speak your mother tongue.
http://fixyourpc.miniblog.pl/
I won't be so sure that the Dutch could enjoy that as well.

[cheapdresslily]

Took a lot of time to read but I really found this very interesting and informative, thank you buddy for sharing

cheap clothing stores http://www.dresslily.com/

[D]

So appreciate for teaching me a lot! charmingdate

[俊]

I sincerely hope that you keep up with the good job conducted..
www.hqew.net

[Rose Yeung]

Thanks for sharing this information its really nice.thai brides

[Eva Rasmussen]

I have both breeds. My father is an American and my mother is a Dutch. For me, Dutch is far better than my American countrymen.

[Ojal Madhavi]

It twists out that the respond to the query depends very a great deal on anywhere in the profits sharing we look at want term paper help!!

[Broad Paul]

Laura Ashley, Inc., also had a booming catalogue business. The designer has risen from her modest London apartment to head an entire home furnishings empire. london apartments

[Islerguclerizle]

Thanks for sharing this information its really nice

işler güçler izle
işler güçler
işler güçler dizi bölümleri
işler güçler 720p izle
işler güçler HD izle
işler güçler izle
işler güçler tek parça izle
işler güçler hangi gün yayınlanıyor
işler güçler son bölüm izle
işler güçler hd izle

[Cometoqiu]

I am truly thankful to the holder of this website who has shared this fantastic piece of writing at at this place.the diet solution

[James]

this is really interesting as well looking like china is betting usa... but we can see that usa is been trying to come out after that recession & still not that much healthy then before.

4insure best car insurance companies

[4uteajason]

I ordered this dress for a prom and I was very impressed with it! I actually ordered it.
The quality of the dress is really impressive, much better made than a lot of dresses here in Perth. Decent padded bust support is built into the dresses. The stitching is perfect, the lining is really lovely, as was the chiffon fabric (no pulls or loose stitching etc). The colours of the dresses all matched and were all as they looked in the photos on the website. http://www.promstreet.com

[Allen Wise]

Europe is the best place to live in my mind.

Details information at http://www.hqew.net/news/

[Surud]

I am still thinking whether americans better than the dutch as I am thinking how to belajar bahasa inggris and how to know kata mutiara..

[yoetama]

Both have different sides and other countries should follow the example so that it could also be better. http://yoetama.blogspot.com/2012/10/fortuner-suv-terbaik.html

[Jimmy Jam]

income may be distributed more unequally in the U.S., but that is largely irrelevant. As the chart below shows, very few Chinese are richer than the poorest Americans. local seo

[Jimmy Jam]

So our inclination may be to answer in the affirmative. But when average incomes do not differ by a large margin, income distributions do matter a lot. It turns out that the answer to the question depends very much on where in the income distribution we look at.seo services

[Calvin Brock]

the military, to heel – a mammoth court case in which hundreds of officers are charged with plotting a coup against you – is based on bogus evidence. Páginas Amarillas

[Calvin Brock]

this is the really interesting part -- this happens regardless of the quality of domestic policies, institutions, or geography. Manufacturing productivity converges even if you are in a remote country with lousy policies and institutions. moving to london

[Okadapter]

that is nice. information is useful. LCD ScreenI am happy to find this post very useful for me,

[Profhariz]

I Like ur article iPhone 5 Gadget Impian

[Jerry John]

They should take up building BVLGARI Watches dams for power generation. We should FRANCK MULLER watches learn from china. china manufacturing

[Okadapter]

laptop ac adapter
laptop lcd screenDell Laptop AC AdaptersHP Laptop AC Adapters

Compaq Laptop AC Adapters
good post

[Happy Adapter]

hp pavilion dv4000 ac adapter
hp dv5000 adapter
hp zv5000 adapter
hp pavilion zd7000 adapter
hp pavilion zt3000 ac adapter

[Claudio Timbers]

es, income may be distributed more unequally in the U.S., but that is largely irrelevant. As the chart below shows, very few Chinese are richer than the poorest Americans. The distributions of income for the two countries barely overlap. Unlock here

[Rastia Rigie]

Bank Mandiri Bank Terbaik di Indonesia
Bank Mandiri Bank Terbaik di Indonesia
Promo Bonus 100% Sbobet, Ibcbet dan Casino Online Dalam Rangka HUT BAVETLINE Yang Kedua
Masterbet88 Grand Opening Promo Bonus 50% Sportsbook dan Casino Online

[Barricasyvino]

Thanks Sir, it’s better now. I used it on one of my newest projects and i love it. Thanks. barricas
wine barrel
wooden barrel
f

[Okadapter]

laptop ac adapter
Compaq Laptop AC Adapters
HP Laptop AC Adapters
Dell Laptop AC Adapters

[Tom Watson]

d a radical fiscal contraction that pushed the country back into external surplus. The shock produced a loss of output of almost 20% of GDP in one year, and a rise in unemployment to 18.4% (from 6% in 2007). By 2011, the worst seemed over and the economy grew at a healthy rate of 5.5%, one of the highest in Europe. Matawan Tax Return Service

[Okadapter]

Dell Latitude D820 AC Adapter
Dell Latitude D620 Adapter
Dell Inspiron E1505 AC Adapter

[penny]

As we known,the U.S. is a very rich country in the world.But in fact,we can not confirm which is richer in Americans or in Ducth?
Toshiba laptop adapter
Lenovo adapters

[Facebook Apps Maker]

I am fulfilled to find this post very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I always want to research the amazing content and this factor I found in you post.

Mobile Application Development Company US

[David Rice]

Thank you so much for writing a lot of this good information..

Dissertation Writing

[Facebook Apps Maker]

Your post is really informative,and i like your post a lot.Thanks a lot for sharing such a useful information.
App Facebook Developers

[Jerry Leo]

Many thanks for this have been searching everywhere for it!
Desarrollo De Aplicaciones

[Okadapter]

Dell Latitude D520 AC Adapter
Dell PA-6 AC Adapter
Dell Vostro 1000 Adapter
Dell XPS M1210 Adapter

[Okadapter]

dell inspiron 1520 ac adapter
dell PA-12 adapter

Acer Aspire 3000 ac adapter
Acer Aspire 3500 ac adapter
Dell Inspiron 1000 ac adapter

[Alex Clark]

Thank you for sharing your new site. Keep up the great work.

Online Assignment Writing

[Spektruder.wordpress.com]

It is very nice to have you online again. I'm truly sorry because I’ve cannot quite often to see your new articles due to my

mobile activity over the last couple months, it's because now I work in Indonesia and helping people here. I see that you're now has update your website with lots of great article and it's good. No, it is really great. If you have much time, please come to my web too because I have a pleasant article about Iconia PC tablet dengan Windows 8 really good too for review. I look forward to have you there and please commenting one or two and give me a feedback related to my review. Last but not least, it's been a joyful moment reading your review. Regards,
Jejak-jejak maya

[Alex Clark]

This is really awesome blog and the information is more awesome and great to see!
emf detector

[Alex Clark]

I like this post a lot and it contains a lot of great points and obsessions!

Fine Arts Portrait

[Bernard Atkinson]

This my pleasure to get information here about...!
UK Writing

[Muhammad Ikhsan Yuniarka]

Nice information.. Thank's a lot form the information | Jam Tangan Original Murah

[Artikapurnamasari92]

good article

Harga samsung galaxy

[Fix-howto.blogspot.com]

yes This is really awesome blog and the information is more awesome and great to see!
kata bijak kehidupan
kemeja pria
auto 2000 bandung
harga hp terbaru
hresult 0xc8000222
cara kerja internet

[D]

American and dutch all is Good
http://busana-pria.com/ulasan-mengenai-jas/jas-pengantin-2>Anchor Text
http://www.busana-pria.com>Anchor Text

[D]

Very usefull article

http://busana-pria.com/ulasan-mengenai-jas/jas-pengantin-2

http://www.busana-pria.com

[D]

it's because now I work in Indonesia and helping people here.

Jual Rumah Alam Sutera
Rumah Di Jual Di Alam Sutera
Jual Rumah Di Alam Sutera
Rumah Dijual Alam Sutera
Rumah Di Alam Sutera
Rumah Alam Sutera
Rumah Dijual Alam Sutera Serpong

[D]

nice post.
Rumah Gading Serpong
Rumah Di Gading Serpong
Rumah Dijual Gading Serpong
Gading Serpong Rumah Dijual
Jual Rumah Gading Serpong
Rumah Dijual Di Gading Serpong
Dijual Rumah Gading Serpong

[D]

Good Articles
Jual Rumah Bsd
Rumah Dijual Bsd
Rumah Bsd Dijual
Rumah Dijual Di Bsd
Jual Rumah Bsd Serpong
Rumah Bsd
Rumah Di Bsd

[Devid778]

Barnabas

[D]

very very nice article
www.busana-pria.com
http://busana-pria.com/ulasan-mengenai-jas/jas-pria-dan-pesonanya

[sabil]

I sincerely hope that you keep up with the good job conducted..
Cream Pembesar Penis
Cream Pembesar Alat Vital
Cream Pemanjang Penis
Cream Kuda Hitam
Cream Kuda Jantan

[KSP LESTARI]

Good..
http://www.indonesian.my.id/2016/07/ramuan-cara-menurunkan-berat-badan-yang-ampuh.html

[Rick William]

Great article sir keep it up!

Shipping Restrictions Magento 2 Extension

[Rick William]

nice article sir keep it up!!

Shipping Restrictions Magento 2 Extension