Wolf on Spence (and Easterly)

I agree with Martin Wolf's take on the Spence commission report on growth, and his put-down of Bill Easterly's column:

Contrary to what Prof Easterly argues, the report makes useful contributions to policymakers’ understanding. The most important is the emphasis on growth itself, underplayed by many advisers and activists in the 1990s and early 2000s. Growth is not everything. But it is the foundation for everything. The poorer the country the more important growth becomes, partly because it is impossible to redistribute nothing and partly because higher incomes make a huge difference to the welfare of the poorest.

Yet the report goes beyond that. It is based on an analysis of 13 countries that have managed growth of 7 per cent a year over at least 25 years. They are diverse: Botswana, Brazil, China, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Japan, South Korea, Malaysia, Malta, Oman, Singapore, Taiwan and Thailand. India and Vietnam seem likely to join this group. These countries have not all sustained their growth: Brazil and Indonesia are important examples of backsliding. These countries are also different in many respects, notably in their size, resources and culture.

Yet, suggests the report, they shared five points of resemblance: they fully exploited the opportunities afforded by the world economy; they maintained macroeconomic stability; they sustained high rates of saving and investment; they let markets allocate resources; and they had committed, credible and capable governments.

These points are consistent with the so-called “Washington consensus” of the 1990s, which emphasised macroeconomic stability, trade and the market. Yet the report’s emphasis is different: it does not stress privatisation, free markets and free trade, while it does emphasise the role of the so-called “developmental state”.

I think Martin was ill-served by the  FT editor who chose his title.  His column bears the heading "Useful do's and don’ts for an economy set on fast growth," whereas a key point of the Spence report--with which Martin seems to agree--is that while we can agree on the key ingredients of growth, the way to achieve these varies greatly from setting to setting. 

As for Bill Easterly, I'm afraid Dingel put it best: "If you're overconfident about development, Bill Easterly pokes holes in your arguments. And if you're modest, he makes fun of you." 

Comments

[minny mouse]

I am always confused by the claim that countries like China, Japan, and South Korea allow markets to function despite massive state intervention. None of the three resemble Hong Kong in terms of "free" markets.

Or it is just that they intervene relatively less than other developed countries. I always found that this was a distinction that is played down in these conversations.

[robertdfeinman]

There is still a fundamental problem with the international development community. What "works" in one time and place doesn't work elsewhere, or it stops working. Each time this happens there are ad hoc explanations given.

The "big thinkers" all try to find some overall rule which can cover everything: local control, free trade, debt forgiveness, etc. That there are so many theories just shows that none of them are very convincing.

Then the idea of "growth" gets blurred by how it is defined. Is growth measured by GDP or other macro measures, or is the criteria that which boosts the poorest the most?

Even if it is the latter, then using percentages is also misleading. Obviously high percentage growth rates are easy to achieve when the base is small. Going from $1 to $1.30 sounds great as a percentage, but how much does this really help the poor?

Perhaps there are already studies that I've not seen, but I'd like to see the relationship between elimination of poverty and the amount of democracy in a state. The measure of democracy has to be sufficiently clever to measure real democracy and not just nominal actions like elections.

By such a measure, the US hasn't been very democratic, 60% of the people favor universal health care and have for 60 years, but it hasn't happened. So much for the will of the people.

Since most people's lives are controlled by large institutions (church, education, employer) and since none of these have democratic governance looking at the choices for government officials is inadequate.

It seems that everyone in this field starts with their own ideological prejudices and then finds data to support this. No wonder progress has been so spotty.

I claim (with no data to present) that those societies which allow the will of the people to be best expressed perform the best economically. I also claim that this connection is unpalatable to the plutocrats who own and run things and to their paid lackeys who promote their interests through a barrage of theories, and that's why it's not considered.

I'm not talking about economic systems, but systems of governance.

[FT]

Dingel also said "Of course, Easterly also has a serious point to make."

[James Edwards]

Dani, you misundertood the title of the article by Martin Wolf, it is not trying to give to the readers of the article a list of dos and donts but its instead encompassing the topic of dos and donts in a debate.

[jose carlos]

on "what is good for growth is good for development", it assumes we can ALWAYS redistribute from winners to losers. plenty of reasons that is not true, right? the policy world reflects nowadays, for instance, on the environment and excluded groups --indigenous peoples in particular.
so, are oil and food prices good for amazon peoples in ecuador?
it is not that straight forward... are we going to keep talking nation-level claiming strong assumptions and lack of data?

[Jamus Lim]

I just came from a talk by Bill Easterly at Brookings that was centered on his FT column.

My beef with this claim comes from the implicit assumption that the solution to development is to simply allow individual liberty. Now, I have no problems with individual freedom. My problem is the belief that this liberalization can occur spontaneously once we recognize that this is what is required. In some ways, this seems almost tautological: Does not economic freedom simply imply getting the hell out of the interventionist policy? Perhaps it does, but we have too many examples of how letting things rip does not bring freedom to pass. Thus, even if we accept Easterly's premise that liberty is the solution, we are far from understanding the mechanisms that can bring about such liberty.

Consider Russia. What we have there today---normal country notwithstanding---is a form of wild-west capitalism where economic freedom mingles with multiple failures in the rule of law. There is a whole literature on transition economics that argues over whether big-bang or small-step (economic) liberalization is the better strategy. The literature on democratic transitions is similarly mixed in its understanding of key drivers of the process, noncredible transfers notwithstanding. Moreover, political freedom appears to be neither necessary nor sufficient for economic growth. While democracy may be a laudable goal in and of itself, the linkages between democracy and development are tenuous at best, and is much more likely to be a second rather than first-order effect.

Likewise, more than two decades of experience with Latin America and elsewhere has taught us that financial repression is widespread among developing countries. Trade restrictions are similarly common, and despite substantial progress over the past century, remain bones of contention in international economic relations. Hyperinflationary economies encourage speculation and profiteering, rather than legitimate economic activity. All over the world, we see macroeconomic policy failures that result from a poor understanding of what not to do when it comes to macroeconomic management.

Finally, the many state failures in Africa point to how social and civil conflict can drive out any semblance of economic activity and lead to breakdowns in the society and economy. These failures are potentially preventable, but require that we build institutions that can help mitigate the multiplicity of interests arising from heterogeneous actors in society. While institution-building is often a painfully slow and laborious process---with tremendous uncertainty---we do know that easing pre-conflict tensions and bringing about post-conflict stability is possible, and attainable in a remarkably short time span.

The point is that government policymakers and political-economic actors do not stand still just because individual liberty is a laudable objective, whether philosophically or pragmatically speaking. If we want to relax the constraints faced by agents in the economy in order to unlease the forces of bottom-up growth, we need to understand the institutional constraints faced by these agents operating in that economy, and in so doing, engage in governance reforms that would facilitate their private actions. After all, it is not difficult to imagine how a talented, enterprising young individual can choose to be a paramilitary leader, a robber baron, or exploitative dictator, rather than a business magnate or financial manager, if the institutional environment rewarded the former professions more richly than the latter. In order to make progress in development, we still need to understand how political economies work, and help real-world economies achieve the best institutional environment possible. This is also consistent with many of your views, Dani, on experimentation in development macro and your work on growth diagnostics.

[OS]

Those 13 countries are diverse in what sense? 9 of them are in East Asia. 7 of them have Chinese majorities or large Chinese minorities that played a key role in development. 3 of the 4 outside the Pacific Rim have populations below 3 million. So that would seem to leave Brazil as the only non-tiny, non-Pacific growth success story (terrible income inequality, anyone?). The report is interesting but let's not take the "spin" too far... it's still basically about how the rest of the world can learn from East Asia.

As for Bill Easterly, it's disappointing to see such smart people develop a chip on their shoulder and become so grumpy against everyone else (see also Stiglitz and Sachs).

[N]

Good to see Easterly's column attracting some high-profile and well- deserved criticism. I've always found his gadfly routine to be somewhat tiresome, all the more so when employed to back up a recitation of vapid libertarian dogmas (as in his FT column).

Medical experts have yet to come up with a single set of therapies or medications that can be uniformly applied to every medical condition. According to Easterly's reasoning, this would seem to suggest that medical expertise is a myth, and that the "medical expert" paradigm has collapsed. Even so, I imagine that Easterly occasionally visits the doctor.

[Dan Nicolai]

My concern about Wolf's argument is that higher incomes only "make a huge difference to the welfare of the poorest" if their incomes are the ones increasing. The radical (and increasing) inequality in most of the "success stories" calls this into question; interestingly, while Brazil may be "backsliding" in his view, its economy is finally beginning to address inequality of income opportunity.

[Ken Houghton]

"If you're overconfident about development, Bill Easterly pokes holes in your arguments. And if you're modest, he makes fun of you."

And that's why The White Man's Burden is so egregious, while The Elusive Quest for Growth was just written backwards.

[rado watches]

Why is everyone just montblanc watches willing to accept power cuts? Don't you think that patek philippe watches having continious power is your right? If people aren't going to demand rado watches 24X7 power, don't expect anything zenith watches to change. The government needs to look at other sources parmigiani watches of power generation. The only solution is more power panerai watches production. Nothing less.
http://www.watchvisa.com/montblanc-watches.html
http://www.watchvisa.com/patek_philippe-watches.html
http://www.watchvisa.com/rado-watches.html
http://www.watchvisa.com/tudor-watches.html

[rolex watches]

People usually say :"Seeing is believing." http://www.tt88times.com
Each attempt has a corresponding gain, in part or obvious, or vague. At least we have the kind of satisfaction After I bought this watch ,in a sense,it means a great deal to me. http://www.fashionhairfu.com

[ghd straighteners]

GHD straighteners was kmown as ghd flat iron, which was authorized online seller provides all kinds of hair straighteners,pink ghd,purple ghd,babyliss. By visiting ghd australia , you will find what you want and made yourself more beautiful.If you miss it ,you miss beauty.Buy a piece of ghd for yourself.Come and join us http://www.ghdoutlet-au.com/ to win the ghd iv styler.

[generic cialis]

In the 1950s and 60s (and even now), there was a pervasive, fairly
specific cultural myth of the mating behavior of cavemen, where the
caveman would club a woman over the head, and drag her by her hair to
his cave. This of course bears no resemblance to anything in real
prehistory.

[birkenstock]

Birkenstock was Made in Germany since 1774 . Check out our Birkenstock sandals and Birkenstock shoes including the Birkenstock gizeh,at the lowest regular outlet prices, free shipping and when you put on Birkenstocks. you will feel very comfortable.

[Nike Air Jordan]

The good news, thank you!

[ghdstraighteners-au]

the superb quality and beautiful salon-perfect hair performance that only comes with ghd straighteners.

www.ghdstraighteners-au.com

[lachou]

I like these articles , democratic countries formulate policies are both team and the interests of the people of power, but the undemocratic countries rarely for the interests of the people, http://www.jerseysky.com it is the sorrow of many democracy, I like the western and northern state policy.
http://www.cheapsaleing.com
http://www.nikeairmaxshoe.ocm

[lv store]

It seems that everyone in this field starts with their own ideological prejudices and then finds data to support this. No wonder progress has been so spotty.]]

[jordan shoes]

I am happy to find this post very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I always prefer to read the quality content and this thing I found in you post. Thanks for sharing.

[jordan shoes]

I am happy to find this post very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I always prefer to read the quality content and this thing I found in you post. Thanks for sharing.

[cheap jordans]

Thanks a lot for sharing. You have done a brilliant job. Your article is truly relevant to my study at this moment, and I am really happy I discovered your website. However, I would like to see more details about this topic. I'm going to keep coming back here.

[jordan shoes]

I’ve seen progression in every post. Your newer posts are simply wonderful compared to your posts in the past. Keep up the good work!

[groysman]

in law4all there is alot of layers and articles for free

[groismen]

http://psakdin.law4all.co.il aloow you to search free court ruling
in psakdin.law4all.co.il you can find more then 500000 court ruling and layers

[alon]

I remembered that my brother bought, September home theater system systems. He told me that you can also get a home cinema system, sound systems, speaker system, sound equipment, speakers, events, speakers on sale, home theater receiver, amplifiers for events, speakers, home theater and stereo systems.
מערכת קולנוע ביתי

[benda]

Avi Ben David, chairman of Ashdod Ashkelon Branch Bureau insurance agent insurance agents licensed in property, life, health, and more days. The firm works with leading companies such as: general, Phoenix, lamp, complete, and more. Insurance Agency cousin We guarantee a personal response , efficient, dedicated and above all professional

[netta]

Understanding of musical terms, reading notes, correct posture, control of the respiratory system, diaphragm and stomach muscles, open mouth and throat, shading, reverberation, sound and power flow of voice, tones, pronunciation, listening, listening to self-escort ... It's hard

https://www.nettamusic.com

[Pony furniture]

I ordered my house these guys huge closet, highly recommend.
Pony furniture, custom furniture manufacturing and planning Myakcoaeime Pony specialize in the manufacture of furniture, kitchens, bedrooms, closets, cabinets and bath ...
http://www.pony.co.il
מטבחים

[SHAFRAR]

Wedding Day contains countless wonderful moments filled with emotion, laughter, love and friendship. My job is to collect them all to create the perfect be remembered forever. Beyond professionalism in photography is important for me to give my customers a service ratio
http://www.gadartphoto.com
צילום אומנותי - גד שפרר-גד שפרר

[asus]

Business Consulting - Daphne vigor "look through" cleaning intention healing transformation and communications consultancy. Guidance and counseling Guided channeling imagination. Couples counseling and self-awareness training. Teacher engaged in energetic healing spiritual meditation and treatment

[nail]

Abigail is a champion of the OMC nail art in Israel in 2009. ABIGAIL courses, workshops and products ABIGAIL pedicure! Come learn how to be a champion in building expert nail
http://www.abigail.co.il
קורס בניית ציפורניים-אביגיל

[amir]

About 6 years. Business and began specializing in work refurbishing and changing houses, apartments and institutions.

http://www.berco100.com

שיפוץ בתים

[yuval]

Windows 2003 - is a general level executive jobs and cleaning windows in particular. Israel's leading company in the oldest works abseiling window cleaning height
Serves customers throughout the country. Among the services the company provides include: cleaning windows, cleaning windows, cleaning company, maintenance and cleaning company, cleaning and maintenance Buildings, abseiling cleaning, sealing, cleaning, rappelling, window cleaning center, cleaning windows and curtain walls (glass) by the death of the plateau.
Abseiling window cleaning, window cleaning in private homes and institutions, cleaning windows (display cases), the current window cleaning, window cleaning using Telescopes (extend) tall ladders, washing and cleaning of building facades (Mosaic, ceramic, marble aluminum) pressure water cleaning high windows.
. Yuval -054-2460585
www.halonot2003.com
ניקוי חלונות

[motorslavi]

Site Mdbym experienced riders - Lavie Motors, a garage and store motorcycles and scooters from the center. Sale of motorcycle gear and helmets, motorcycles and scooters rentals, garage motorcycles and scooters shop imports second hand scooters.

http://www.lavimotors.co.i
השכרת קטנועים - לביא מוטורס-אבי

[gal]

Mira Gal. Personal trainer to improve and strengthen self-confidence, coping with stage fright fear public. Pianist. Coach and accompanies singers (Korafteicia.) Mental preparation before the show. Exercises to release tension, external appearance. Working on posture and walking and standing on a stage. Practice body language. Speech and breathing technique. Expression
A - here. Voice and sound. Intonation and tone of speech pronunciation right. Diction. Help build Present practice. Accompaniment and support after the performance and preparation for continued success.
http://www.miragalcoach.com
מירה גל מאמנת אישית-מירה גל

[Pdoriano]

Shirley Pdoriano- atmosphere paintings original oil paintings, colorful Studio Gallery, opened into the world, world views and rich colors, textures, materials, techniques and genres, including landscapes, flowers and exotic trees, abstract, figurative nude paintings atmosphere
http://www.sp-art.co.il
ציורי אוירה

[chrome]

Marvalous company markets nutritional supplements revolutionary breakthrough by this patent is active in the field of quality health and wellness including cold press oil derived from plant seeds networked sage is amazingly fast and is active against many diseases and health problems to life-saving
http://www.patentisraeli.co.il
אומגה 3 תוספי תזונה-זאב קרום

[shlomovich]

urgent medicine,firat aid courses,varied lectures and workshops,medical consultation for institutions
http://www.premergency.co.il
קורס עזרה ראשונה
עזרה ראשונה

[shlomovich]

עיסוק בתחומים רבים בתחום הרפואה הדחופה,מעבירה קורס עזרה ראשונה ברמה,הרצאות וסדנאות מגוונות,יעוץ רפואי למוסדות ובתי עסק,מקימה צוותי חירום במפעלים,שירות אמבולנסים פרטיים,העברה מוטסת וליווי חולים בחו"ל,מעניקה ציוד רפואי איכותי במחירים טובים. קורס עזרה ראשונה,ערכת עזרה ראשונההדרכות עזרה ראשונה,ערכת החייאה.
http://www.premergency.co.il
קורס עזרה ראשונה אנו ניתן לכם את היכולת להציל חיים!

[netta]

Understanding of musical terms, reading notes, correct posture, control of the respiratory system, diaphragm and stomach muscles, open mouth and throat, shading, שיעורי מוזיקה בשרוןreverberation, sound and power flow of voice, tones, pronunciation, listening, listening to self-escort ... It's hard. http://www.nettamusic.com/

[benita]

renew and fix furniture for office and institusion. computer desk,waiting chairריהוט משרדי

[clear]

How to choose a maid? I heard about the company Kelerne "cleaning services to a very high level in the central region and Surrounding areas.Something

[printer]

Toner cartridges are actually printed material powder that laser printers and copiers used it by laser technology that warms http://www.givunim.com

and determined the powder and ink on the page
טונרים

[w.a.]

if analyze this carrefully you can easely discover something new

[israel]

Group of purchasers is the next trend in Israeli real estate,קבוצת רכישה we hear of

more and more buyers Vkobucut buying groups purchase apartments from a contractor organized and promising buyers themselves are fixed

at a price that they are safely Shlharoachs apartment at the time of receiving a fixed and known date of Entry. http://www.activeisrael.co.il

[Pdoriano]

techniques and genres, including landscapes, flowers and exotic trees, abstract, figurative nude paintings atmosphere
http://www.sp-art.co.il
ציורי אוירה

[Account Deleted]

raf

Thanks for article.

[Mirav Shivuck]

חברת מירב שיווק היא מהוותיקות ביותר בשוק הפרסום ומוצרי פרסום לעסקים בישראל. החברה מפיקה מייצרת ומשווקת מוצרי פרסום לכל סוג של בית עסק ומהווה מענה ישיר ומדוייק לכלל סוגי וצורכי הפרסום העסקי בימנו. לדוגמא: עטים לפרסום, כנסו לאתרנו בכתובת http://www.ms2u.net

[Rony Golany]

http://web.2all.co.il>בניית אתרים חינם איזה מערכת מגניבה יש לטו אוול אפשר לבנות אתר תוך מספר דקות ואים מסתבכים יש להם מדריך מפורט לhttp://web.2all.co.il>בניית אתרים
ואם לא מסתדרים גם עם זה אפשר פשוט להתקשר לתמיכה שלהם והם עוזרים גם ב בניית אתרים חינמים פשוט כיך נוח וקל, מערכת ידידותית
אני בניתי כבר ארבע אתרים מגניבים עם פונקציות שהם בטואוול נתנו לי כמו הוספת משחקים ועוד המון דברים עברתי על כל מי שמספק שירותי בניית אתרים והמערכת שלהם הכי קלה ונוחה פשוט מומלץ

תהנו בהצלחה זו כתובת האתר שלהם: http://web.2all.co.il

[Rony Golany]

סליחה סליחה התבלבלתי
http://web.2all.co.il>בניית אתרים חינם איזה מערכת מגניבה יש לטו אוול אפשר לבנות אתר תוך מספר דקות ואים מסתבכים יש להם מדריך מפורט לhttp://web.2all.co.il>בניית אתרים
ואם לא מסתדרים גם עם זה אפשר פשוט להתקשר לתמיכה שלהם והם עוזרים גם ב בניית אתרים חינמים פשוט כיך נוח וקל, מערכת ידידותית
אני בניתי כבר ארבע אתרים מגניבים עם פונקציות שהם בטואוול נתנו לי כמו הוספת משחקים ועוד המון דברים עברתי על כל מי שמספק שירותי בניית אתרים והמערכת שלהם הכי קלה ונוחה פשוט מומלץ

תהנו בהצלחה זו כתובת האתר שלהם: http://web.2all.co.il

[Account Deleted]

Raf
raf

raf,raf sistemleri

[Account Deleted]

Raf
raf

Thanks for this ...

[Yoni Yoni]

תאוריה בטסט ראשון
האתר מספר אחת ללמודי תאוריה טסט ראשון מציע לכם את כל מגוון שיטות הלימוד להצלחה בטוחה במבחן תאוריה ובמבחן טסט
לומדים מצליחים ועוברים את התאוריה והטסט כבר בפעם הראשונה.

[Account Deleted]

Many places and centers offer business and trade promotions to both buyers and supplier.What about the differences in skill intensities across industries? The job losses in the relatively unskilled-labor intensive battery industry should have little effect on the relatively skilled-labor intensive machinery
sexshop
sexyshop
sexshop online
alongador peniano

[D]

מ.מ.ש פלג הינה חברה ל עיבוד שבבי השוכנת בראשון לציון
בעלת 40 שנות ניסיון בענף העיבוד השבבי.
ייחודיותנו בא לידי ביטוי בפיתוח מודלים, אבי טיפוס, ליווי הנדסי, ייעוץ ומתן פתרונות מתרולוגיים וייצור.
יכולותיו של העסק משלבות את כל פתרונות במקום אחד, ובכך מספקות מענה לכל בעיה ודרישה של הלקוח, תוך חיסכון

בזמן ובכסף עבורו
חברתינו ידועה כמי שמוכנה להתמודד עם חלקים מסובכים ופרוייקטים מורכבים בייצור פריטים לפי הזמנה, במקצועיות

רבה ובמחירים הוגנים.
עיבוד שבבי, עיבוד שבבי במרכז, אב טיפוס, חריטה וכרסום, ייצור חלקים ודגמים, פיתוח פטנטים, בניית מכונות הרכבות מכניות

[Doron Cohen]

ביגמיה לדעת הרב עובדיה יוסף ופוליגמיה, הכל על ריבוי נשים, דעותיהם של: הרמב"ם, הבבא סאלי, הרב קוק , דניאל אמבש.
הבית היהודי השלם, הרב מרדכי אליהו. ביגמיה פוליגמיה

[Gethiv]

Have you noticed the news has changed its method recently? Power Mind Control

[Account Deleted]

The positive comments and do well wishes are very motivational and greatly appreciated.

organic seo service

[Account Deleted]

powerpoint recovery file

Thanks for the interesting article!

[Rony Golany]

חברת חמד מומחית בכל ענפי הגובה, סנפלינג עבודות בגובה עם סנפלינג, אטום תפרים ,צביעת מבנים וניקוי חלונות של מבנים גבוהים עבודות גובה
עבודות בגובה

[Beni Leibzon]

"אגרות קודש
כותבים לרבי ורואים ישועות אלפי אנשים בכל העם מקבלים עצות ונושעים בכל יום על ידי התקשרות לרבי.
בואו לקחת חלק ולכתוב גם אתם לרבי מילובביץ' בכל צרה בעיה ובקשה כותבים באגרות הקודש ומקבלים תשובה מהרבי
לכתיבה לרבי ב אגרות קודש "
אגרות קודש

[Beni Leibzon]

מזל טוב! זה היום שחיכיתם לו כבר הרבה זמן, אתם כבר בני 16 וכבר ממתינים בקוצר רוח לעבור טסט ולקרוע את המדינה (בזהירות כמובן) עם הרכב של ההורים. אז רגע לפני, תרשו לנו קצת לצנן את ההתלהבות ולהתעכב קצת על כמה פרטים קטנים ומאד חשובים שאתם חייבים לעשות ולדעת רגע לפני שאתם נבחנים. בואו ללמוד אצלנו באתר ולהנות מטסטים מצולמים בחינם וממבחני תיאוריה לדוגמא והכל בחינם
תיאוריה

[Beni Leibzon]

מאמרים ודברי תורה על פרשות השבוע. דקדוקי לשון, חידות, מדע בפרשה
פרשת השבוע