Deconstructing economists' take on free trade

Once in a while you come across a paper that makes you nod in agreement and go "yes!" with every sentence you read. Robert Driskill's Deconstructing the Argument for Free Trade is such a paper. Driskill is a distinguished economist who knows the theory of comparative advantage as well as anyone else. And his argument is not against trade per se, but about the manner in which economists present their arguments in public and in their textbooks. His main argument is that the standard renditions

gloss over a key issue the resolution of which is anything but obvious: What does it mean for a change in economic circumstances to be "good for the nation as a whole", even when some members of that nation are hurt by the change?

In other words, instead of sticking to what they are good at--analyzing trade-offs--economists typically engage in amateur normative political theorizing about what is good for society.

Driskill also makes a more fundamental point:

Consider a scene in the movie Dead Poets Society, in which the all-boys-school poetry teacher portrayed by the actor Robin Williams asks his students: What is the purpose of language? They predictably answered: to communicate. Their teacher then corrected them: the purpose of language, he claimed, is to "woo women!"

Of course, in some contexts, wooing women is a worthy goal. But scientific writing about policy issues shouldn't be like writing poetry. Unfortunately, most economic writing on the welfare implications of trade are not a balanced weighing of the evidence or a critical evaluation of the pros and cons of arguments, but rather are more akin to a zealous prosecutor's advocacy of a point of view. As such, this writing is designed to persuade rather than to give the
reader the information needed to form an educated point of view.

...

My point is not that the economics profession is not on the side of angels in the policy debate over trade liberalization--although I will argue that a more careful argument should lead to a more nuanced view--but that the argument is poorly made. This reflects negatively on the credibility of the economics profession as a whole: critical thinkers might believe all economic arguments are as poorly supported as is the one in support of free trade; others might believe economists are mere propagandists and handmaidens in service of some philosophical or political goal. Furthermore, it obscures some key ideas that should be part of a persuasive argument in support of free trade. And finally, it has confused many people into false beliefs about what economic analysis really says about the effects of international trade.

A pervasive such false belief, for example, is that trade necessarily benefits more people than it hurts.

Driskill illustrates his arguments by drawing on the writings of a range of economists, from Deirdre McCloskey to Paul Krugman. You must read this paper if you are an economist (or keep their company). 

Comments

[David Lynch]

Driskill is not altogether fair to Irwin. While Irwin's (2002) "Free Trade Under Fire" may not emphasize the issues Driskill discusses so much, Irwin's (1996) "Against the Tide" highlights the difficulties of making welfare assessments based on changes in aggregate wealth (see Chapter 12, pp. 180-188). Referring to Senior's work, Irwin writes (p. 183): "...the question he was raising was unavoidable: can economic science make ethically neutral statements about the impact of government policy on economic welfare?" Irwin is also careful to note that "The most obvious qualification relates to a weakness in the analogy about how an individual and a country benefit from trade" (p. 219). The paragraph that follows again notes that wealth and welfare are not the same thing, and that distributional issues are likely to loom large.

[jerry]

This reflects negatively on the credibility of the economics profession as a whole: critical thinkers might believe all economic arguments are as poorly supported as is the one in support of free trade; others might believe economists are mere propagandists and handmaidens in service of some philosophical or political goal.

It truly doesn't help that so many free trade supporters have tenure.

Us slobs facing outsourcing can recognize clueless academic ivory tower bullshit when we see it, and being told by the tenured for 20 years now that free trade has benefited everyone because our job insecurity is balanced by the always low prices at Walmart, well, that's what starts mob action....

[Peter]

I’ve just read Driskill’s piece and am less positive about it. My qualms fall into two categories.

1. The “raw” argument about hypothetical compensation is longstanding (e.g. Little) and, in itself, not very interesting. I think Samuelson’s heuristic theorem is a reasonable first approximation, subject to two empirical questions: Are some groups systematically disadvantaged across the sequence of proposed changes? And, how large are the post-hypothetical-compensation gains? In the case of trade, Heckscher-Olin and a growing body of research tell us that the answer to the first question is largely yes; the second is an arena of dispute. I wish the paper had been more focused on the empirical dimension of its critique.

2. The paper skirts the far more important question about trade, whether price equilibration is an appropriate assumption for an empirically useful model. All trade theories I am aware of make this assumption, in the form of taking it as given that a change in the value of imports will be exactly offset by a change in the value of exports, perhaps (in more sophisticated approaches) after a period of transition. Like price equilibration in macro theory, however, this begs the central question. Most popular concerns over trade liberalization are predicated on doubts over whether permitting an expansion of imports will actually result in a corresponding expansion of exports. Mainstream economics errs by regarding this as a theoretical question, subject to axiomatic proof, when it is really empirical. Does the proposed equilibration mechanism, from an initial trade imbalance to exchange rate (or wage or price level) adjustment to trade rebalancing, actually occur in practice? My reading is that the literature on real exchange rate determination does not support this view in any general way. If so, the theorems of trade theorists predicated on price equilibration are irrelevant to the practical concerns of trade policy.

[Bruce Wilder]

I am inclined to second Peter's comment.

The critical issue, here, is not the abstract "quality" of the analytic, a priori argument -- rather it is the factual evidence and the relationship of theory to carefully-considered and interpreted historical experience.

The non-economists, since time immemoriam have said, "well, that may be true in theory, but in the real world . . ." and, frankly, they are right to do so. "In the real world" people are concerned about the effect of "free trade" on economic rents, on the accumulation of capital, on incentives to technological innovation with increasing returns and external economies, imperfect competition etc. "In the real world" of economic relations, with which most people are familiar, the distribution of income is clearly related to institutional details, many of which have no correspondence in a theoretical Heckscher-Ohlin model. "In the real world", for example, gatekeepers, with access control, say, to shelf-space at Wal-Mart or CostCo or Safeway, may make a lot of money, and the highly productive people who make the dental floss or canned pickles sold there, may make very little money.

Economists, generally, are happy to study a Heckscher-Ohlin model, and to feel confident in a dictum, like "exports pay for imports", without ever considering how badly Heckscher-Ohlin models typically fit actual patterns of trade.

A practical policymaker would prefer generalizations grounded in carefully considered factual evidence and historical experience and strategic guidance, to "insights" and bland pieties. But, maybe, that's just me.

[tt]

"Are some groups systematically disadvantaged across the sequence of proposed changes? [...] In the case of trade, Heckscher-Olin and a growing body of research tell us that the answer to the first question is largely yes;"

Peter, which literature are you referring to? Can you mention some papers? Thanks.

[jsalvati]

I second tt's request. is there a review of that literature?
Also, from the paper:

"But the implications of the model for
"gains from trade" should not be used as an argument in favor of a policy of free
trade: it is just not the right model for helping us think about this question."

This seems like a strange statement. You can say that it is not an argument ender, but surely the fact that there is more material wealth with free trade is an argument in its favor.

[Peter]

What is the literature on the distributional effects of trade? It's huge, of course. My summary of the US lit would be that there is consensus on the direction but not the degree of the effect. (Our humble host, DR, has contributed to this body of work.) There are also many studies in Europe and the developing world.

Examples: "Distributional Effects of Globalization in Developing Countries" by Goldberg and Pavcnik (2006) and an older but very interesting NBER paper by Marianne Bertrand, "From the Invisible Handshake to the Invisible Hand? How Import Competition Changes the Employment Relationship" (1999). But one could cite many others.

Is this what you had in mind?

[wjd123]

That "free trade is for the good of the nation" and "more people are helped than hurt" are dubious propositions indeed. Economists are in a position to do the adding and subtraction when it comes to measuring the creation of wealth and its distribution, but they aren't in a position to extract from these numbers value judgments about goodness that are any more valid than the non-economist with his street philosophy or not wanting to compete with workers making twenty-five cents an hour.

For instance, one might agree that free trade creates wealth but does harm to democratic values. That the checks and balances put on power in our political economy are destroyed by increasing corporate power. And one may further believe that that in turn will destroy ones sense of procedural fairness and lead to a sense of take-as-take-can; and finally that mindset will ultimately erode any sense of shared responsibility and social solidarity. How do you subtract ones dread of living in a nation of malcontents with anarchistic values from the economist measures of greater wealth. You can't.

In fact as corporations get more powerful it will be increasing unlikely that such dread will even be measured or heard except as it might apply to marketing and public relations.

Or one might see a global trade without rules leading to economies of scale which in turn will destroy competition and block the creation of wealth; that the wealth created today by free trade will be taken away by tomorrows monopolistic practices; that economist who preach the gospel of free trade are too blinded by today's buying and selling to see the way that leads to salvation; that they will help lead us to partition buy keeping questions of procedural fairness and values from being heard.

So unless one believes that an ever expanding economic pie is always good for nations no matter how that expansion is achieved, can one make the value judgments that free trade is good for the nation and that it helps more people than it hurts.

[Denis Drew]

The Industrial Revolution was good for the nation as a whole -- but reduced the much more productive -- but much more interchangeable workers who now depended on the boss' capital to destitution because of their loss of bargaining power (answer: heavy unionization not common ownership Karl).

[tt]

Thanks, Peter, I was not aware of Bertrand's paper.

My remark on that literature is that it does not pick up any growth effect of trade liberalization (if any, as Dani would remind us).

Also, it focuses, understandably, on specific cases of liberalization but not on sequences of them. I might be hurt today from open markets but benefit tomorrow. It is that "systematically disadvantaged across the sequence of proposed changes" that caught my eye.

I am not claiming that a balance of benefits actually occurs over time, just that I am not aware of any serious study about this issue.

[Robert]

It has been known since 1974 that comparative advantange does not justify the claim that a country with free trade will have more goods to consume than it would have with tariffs. This objection is not about how the non-existent gain from trade is distributed. See http://robertvienneau.blogspot.com/2006/05/unregulated-international-_114890667128392540.html

Of course, mainstream economists just ignore the demonstrations of mistakes in their mathematics.

[Stephen]

Is industrial policy a potential Pareto improvement and if so how would we know?

[dale]

As a layperson looking at this post, I'm struck by the shifting between the terms "free trade", "trade per se", "trade", "trade liberalization", "international trade". Nowhere are the actual, negotiated trade regimes of the past few decades specifically mentioned.

[wjd123]

dale,

As the paper points out the correct description of what has been happening with trade is "trade liberalization," and not "free trade."

I like to call it "free trade as practiced today" to call attention to what we have gotten wrong: that it's not as free as its supporters make it out to be.

There would be nothing wrong in saying "trade liberalization" except for the fact that it just too innocuous a term when it supporters keep calling the process "free trade" with brings with it all the loaded connotations that come with the word "free."

[Septeus7theParaniod]

Oh goody my favorite subject; the fraud that is free trade.

I came to doubt the claims of the free traders not because of any technical problems with the theoretical justifications for the (non)policy but by simply observing that the results that free trade were supposed to produce weren't actually happening.

So rather than debating the technical merits let's get historical and empirical.

The first example is the greatest period of 19th century trade liberalization in Europe.

From 1866 to 1877 free trade practices reached its height highest. However rather creating a period of great economic growth from 1868 to 1870 GNP declined from 1.6% to .6% starting a period know as the great European depression. The turn around, on the overhand, started with the return of protectionism.

Now China practiced liberal trade for 500 years starting in the Sung Dynasty in order to exploit the benefits of sea trade. However this resulted in a Muslim dominated shipped policy with the greater risk being put on the Chinese domestic exporting merchants.

The Muslim traders came to dominate Chinese trade policy much like our transnationals do today.

But when Mongke Khan sent his brother Hulagu to conquer the Middle East. That cut off Muslim support to the Song which then caused the Sung rulers to cannibalize their own economy trying to defend against the Mogul onslaught.

Free Trade always creates interdependency which always leads to foreign domination.

I could go on and on about the hundred of years of Eastern experiments with liberal trade policies which took place 100s of years before Adam Smith wrote a word about economics and trade but what is the point?

We have all decided to go for globalony so don't be surprised when its the only we make in this country.

[David Fine]

"What is the purpose of money?" Also to woo women?

But seriously I have a question about trade liberalization today. How liberal is trade today in 2007? Are there tarrifs on goods? What goods? What are the problem tarrifs? I'm not a big company engaged in international trade, so I don't know the details. How liberal is trade today compared to the 1990s, or 80s, or 70s?

Also, is there inefficient trade going on, where nations export products like apples and expend the energy to transport them to places that grow apples themselves? For an example...

Nice blog, I was referred by Prof. Gabriel Aguilera after a lecture he gave on Mexican politics since the 1995 Financial Crisis.

Best,

Dave Fine

I think life may be repeating itself...

[vivian]

Good News For Christmas promotion(Form 15th Nov. to 29th Dec) , As u order more than $60 from http://www.vegov.com , you can choose a free hat or belt(not included 3A ones) or sungalsses(not included 3A ones), we will add it to your invoice for free .any inquiries will be appreciated

[aion kinah]

Nice post. This post is different from what I read on most blog. And it have so many valuable things to learn.
Thank you for your sharing!

[rolex watches]

This is clearly replica watches the job for our legal fraternity to engage the establishment to necessary breitling watches steps by filing petitions in various courts. IF one fails another should be cartier watches filed taking every one to task. It is rolex watches useless to suggest ways and means to solve tag heuer watches the day to day problem to well paid employees tissot watches of government controlled establishments. Only active omega watches judiciary will resolve this problem.
http://www.watchvisa.com
http://www.watchvisa.com/breitling-watches.html
http://www.watchvisa.com/cartier-watches.html

[rado watches]

Why is everyone just montblanc watches willing to accept power cuts? Don't you think that patek philippe watches having continious power is your right? If people aren't going to demand rado watches 24X7 power, don't expect anything zenith watches to change. The government needs to look at other sources parmigiani watches of power generation. The only solution is more power panerai watches production. Nothing less.
http://www.watchvisa.com/montblanc-watches.html
http://www.watchvisa.com/patek_philippe-watches.html
http://www.watchvisa.com/rado-watches.html
http://www.watchvisa.com/tudor-watches.html

[Air Jordan 19.5]

I could go on and on about the hundred of years of Eastern experiments with liberal trade policies which took place 100s of years before Adam Smith wrote a word about economics and trade but what is the point?

We have all decided to go for globalony so don't be surprised when its the only we make in this country.

[rolex watches]

People usually say :"Seeing is believing." http://www.tt88times.com
Each attempt has a corresponding gain, in part or obvious, or vague. At least we have the kind of satisfaction After I bought this watch ,in a sense,it means a great deal to me. http://www.fashionhairfu.com

[rolex watches]

People usually say :"Seeing is believing." http://www.tt88times.com
Each attempt has a corresponding gain, in part or obvious, or vague. At least we have the kind of satisfaction After I bought this watch ,in a sense,it means a great deal to me. http://www.fashionhairfu.com

[solar street lights]

Thanks for Robert's this mind,this are very good in deconstructing economists.

[mbt shoes sale]

Totally boring. Where is the red and gold colors...? I predict a very low seller....http://www.supermbtshoes.com

[gucci outlet]

you may have got a piont of there, but I will still keep up my mind.

[gucci outlet]

you may have got a piont of there, but I will still keep up my mind.

[gucci sneakers]

you may have got a piont of there, but I will still keep up my mind.

[tiffany jewelry]

you may have got a piont of there, but I will still keep up my mind.

[watches sale]

I will still keep up my mind

[Nike Air Jordan]

nothing is impossible.

[replica rolex paypal]

私はアメリカではないので、ブログの記事は、よく書かれて、私はとても好き読み取り、すべての単語の私は非常に理解、ほとんどまだ読んでいないが、私はあなたの資料では、知識を学ぶことを望んでまた、我々は良い友達になることを願って。ありがとうございました！ ！

[http://www.mbtsandal.com]

Your passion walker fitness or weight in different ways? Is there a better option is to MBT M.WALK shoes. Your shoes will improve posture, strengthen the main battle tanks for sale many different muscles and help burn more calories. But you may decide to buy a stumbling block, the price is in his shoes. Not everyone can afford sneakers.The way, we main battle tank manufacturers, direct impact on our health. If we go straight to the Health and spinal cord is still the correct position of the knee. On the contrary, if we follow the wrong attitude, we have to have some physical pain.
So I decided to go to Marseilles, Discount MBT Sport Shoes, barefoot shoes clean technology. The technology for the manufacture of main battle tanks and sports shoes.
Doctors and physical therapists are so fascinated, their ultimate use and recommend these MBT Sport Grey shoes, their patients.

[timberland 6 inch boots]

There were timberland 6 inch sensitivity and a beauty to her that have nothing to do with timberland 6 inch boots looks. She was one to be listened to, whose words were so easy to take to timberland boots sale heart.I used to find notes left in the collection basket, beautiful timberland boots outlet notes about my homilies and about the writer's black timberland boots thoughts on the daily scriptural readings. The person who penned the notes mens timberland boots would add reflections to my thoughts and would always include some timberland pro boots quotes from poets and mystics he or she had white timberland boots read and remembered and loved. The notes fascinated black timberland shoes uk me. Here was someone immersed in a search for truth and beauty. Words had been cheap timberland boots treasured, words that were beautiful. And I felt as if the words timberland waterproof boots somehow delighted in being discovered, for they were obviously very generous to the as yet anonymous timberland work boots writer of the notes. And now this person was in turn learning the secret of sharing them. Beauty so shines when given away. The only truth that exists timberland hiking boots is, in that sense, free. http://www.timberland6inch.com/

[timberland 6 inch]

There were timberland 6 inch sensitivity and a beauty to her that have nothing to do with timberland 6 inch boots looks. She was one to be listened to, whose words were so easy to take to timberland boots sale heart.I used to find notes left in the collection basket, beautiful timberland boots outlet notes about my homilies and about the writer's black timberland boots thoughts on the daily scriptural readings. The person who penned the notes mens timberland boots would add reflections to my thoughts and would always include some timberland pro boots quotes from poets and mystics he or she had white timberland boots read and remembered and loved. The notes fascinated black timberland shoes uk me. Here was someone immersed in a search for truth and beauty. Words had been cheap timberland boots treasured, words that were beautiful. And I felt as if the words timberland waterproof boots somehow delighted in being discovered, for they were obviously very generous to the as yet anonymous timberland work boots writer of the notes. And now this person was in turn learning the secret of sharing them. Beauty so shines when given away. The only truth that exists timberland hiking boots is, in that sense, free. http://www.timberland6inch.com/

[vinux]

A modern woman must like a modern handbag. It is a must-have fashion accessory for her. Carrying a handbag makes a woman look more elegant. If a woman prefers to be focused, she must be modern and cool. If she prefers to look better, she must have a nice handbag to enhance her look.swiss replica watches

[jordan shoes]

Thanks for sharing your article. I really enjoyed it. I put a link to my site to here so other people can read it. Came across your blog when I was searching bing I have found the bit of info that
I found to be quite useful.

[jordans for sale]

I think this is a great post. One thing that I find the most helpful is number five. Sometimes when I write, I just let the flow of the words and information come out so much that I loose the purpose. It’s only after editing when I realize what I’ve done. There’s defiantly a lot of great tips here I’m going to try to be more aware of.

[jordan shoes]

It's good to see this information in your post, i was looking the same but there was not any proper resource, than now i have the link which i was looking for my research.

[NFL Football Jerseys]

If I speak in the Cheap Authentic NFL Jerseys tongues of men and of angels, but have not love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal. If I have the gift of prophecy and can fathom all mysteries and all Official NFL Jerseys knowledge, and if I have a faith that can move mountains, but have not love, I am nothing. If I give all I possess to the poor and surrender my USA Jerseys Shop body to the flames,but have not love, I gain nothing.Love is patient, NFL Jerseys love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It is not rude, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it NHL Jerseys keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always MLB Jerseys hopes, always perseveres.Love never NHL Hockey Jerseys fails. But where there are prophecies, they will cease; where there are tongues, they will be stilled; where there is knowledge, it will pass away. For we know in part and we prophesy in MLB Baseball Jerseys part, but when perfection comes, the imperfect disappea. When I was a child, I talked like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became NBA Basketball Jerseys man, I put childish ways behind me. Now we see but a poor reflection as in a mirror; then we shall see face to face. Now I know in part; then I shall know fully, even as I am fully known.And now these three remain: faith, hope and NFL Football Jerseys love. But the greatest of these is love. http://www.jersey-usa.com/sitemap.html LIJ

[wholesale new era caps]

We are a professional supplier of cheap LV handbags ,We can assure you the best price in China on the basic of equal condition, because we have own OEM factory, the trade cost will be low. So you can get more whoelsale caps. Credit first, professional service and mutual benefit are our principles. Our aim is geting on well with all of our clients and get a mutual benefit.
We sincerely hope to establish business relationship with you. chanel handbags onlineIf you are interested in our products, please feel free to contact us for further information.

[wholesale new era caps]

My friend told me that this blog is competitive.wholesale new era caps i will read more. Once again great post. You seem to have a good understanding of these themes.When I entering your blog,I felt this . handbags wholesale Come on and keep writting your blog will be more attractive. To Your Success!

Thanks for sharing your article.cheap LV handbags I really enjoyed it. I put a link to my site to here so other people can read it.chanel handbags online Came across your blog when I was searching bing I have found the bit of info that
I found to be quite useful.

[pandora jewellery]

Thanks for Robert's this mind,this are very good in deconstructing economists.

[pandora jewellery]

I could go on and on about the hundred of years of Eastern experiments with liberal trade policies which took place 100s of years before Adam Smith wrote a word about economics and trade but what is the point?

We have all decided to go for globalony so don't be surprised when its the only we make in this country.

[coach handbag]

The common dream of all women is that they want to dress up themselves to be the most focus one in what kind of occasions. And the discount Coach Handbags on sale for women are able to perfectly help you to make the dream come true. All discount coach bags outlet on sale for women are finished with fashionable and popular design at cheap coach outlet store. The rich colors and styles of coach handbags sale from clearance coach handbags outlet let you really appreciate the happiness of enjoying life. Don't hesitate! Buy it!

[Dubai Sale]

Many places and centers offer business and trade promotions to both buyers and suppliers. These promotions are fine as far as low pricing structure is concerned but when it comes to quality, only Dubai promotions are idea and best-suited as per your actual business needs and trading requirements.

[Emu Boots]

Choose a deli that has a superior selection of sandwiches and sides that is sure to satisfy any hunger. Maybe they even offer the option of building your own sandwich. I say building because that's exactly what it will seem like. As you point to this and that, watch intently as the server confidently stacks on a mountain of your favorite meats and cheeses.

[Account Deleted]

yes,Great site. This could probably have the refactoring tag added t it.
http://www.sedanshoppers.se

[Account Deleted]

raf

Thanks so much for article.

[Ning Asics]

can let the "invisible hand" play a role, but, the body is healthy or not, and cold recovery speed and frequency to catch a cold is concerned. Western economic cyclical economic crisis happened,
http://www.mbt-usa.com/
MBT

[Account Deleted]

nice post i like it.srt

[Mbtmbtshoes]

osama bin laden's death to make people feel at some point, but it is the arrival of what the turning point? Nobody know the current this tumultuous period will is what results - Pakistan and Afghanistan disastrous,Coach bags

[Account Deleted]

Driskill illustrates his arguments by drawing on the writings of a range of economists, from Deirdre McCloskey to Paul Krugman. You must read this paper if you are an economist (or keep their company).

[Account Deleted]

Raf
raf

Thanks for this ...

[Android Tablet]

You are very right in all your tohughts. Kudos.

http://www.jinnlife.com/203/cheapest-android-tablet/

[Account Deleted]

Many places and centers offer business and trade promotions to both buyers and supplier.What about the differences in skill intensities across industries? The job losses in the relatively unskilled-labor intensive battery industry should have little effect on the relatively skilled-labor intensive machinery
sexshop
sexyshop
sexshop online

[Account Deleted]

Your post is superb because i am professor and I also searching some topics to teach my student smoothly, here i see one of the best topics, and I hope you also share that type of knowledge in your next one.

organic seo service

[Account Deleted]

You made some good points .I did a little research on the topic and found that most people agree with your blog. Thanks.
medicine forum

[Account Deleted]

am also interested in this topic. I have spent a lot of time on searching this kind of topic. It is very informative.
drug forum

[Account Deleted]

powerpoint file corrupted

Thanks for the interesting article!

[Account Deleted]

Awesome, Very interesting issue that after a very successful. Nicely written article good work ! Thanks for the great piece of sharing. Enjoy to read your write . Thanks a lot
Creating History Together With ArenaBetting Piala Eropa 2012 http://seotoolinfo.com/2012/06/creating-history-creating-history-together-with-arenabetting-piala-eropa-2012/
Agenliga Sebagai Agen Bola Online Untuk Euro 2012 http://seotoolinfo.com/2012/06/agenliga-agenliga-com-sebagai-agen-bola-online-untuk-euro-2012/

[Rastia Rigie]

Bank Mandiri Bank Terbaik di Indonesia
Bank Mandiri Bank Terbaik di Indonesia
Promo Bonus 100% Sbobet, Ibcbet dan Casino Online Dalam Rangka HUT BAVETLINE Yang Kedua
Masterbet88 Grand Opening Promo Bonus 50% Sportsbook dan Casino Online

[Hosneara Begum]

Hi nice Post written by you guys. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site. Thank a ton for such a nice post.

For more information http://www.totalbodynj.com Visit this site.