The inescapable trilemma of the world economy

Sometimes simple and bold ideas help us see more clearly a complex reality that requires nuanced approaches.  I have an "impossibility theorem" for the global economy that is like that. It says that democracy, national sovereignty and global economic integration are mutually incompatible: we can combine any two of the three, but never have all three simultaneously and in full.

Here is what the theorem looks like in a picture:

To see why this makes sense, note that deep economic integration requires that we eliminate all transaction costs traders and financiers face in their cross-border dealings. Nation-states are a fundamental source of such transaction costs. They generate sovereign risk, create regulatory discontinuities at the border, prevent global regulation and supervision of financial intermediaries, and render a global lender of last resort a hopeless dream. The malfunctioning of the global financial system is intimately linked with these specific transaction costs.

So what do we do?

One option is to go for global federalism, where we align the scope of (democratic) politics with the scope of global markets. Realistically, though, this is something that cannot be done at a global scale. It is pretty difficult to achieve even among a relatively like-minded and similar countries, as the experience of the EU demonstrates.

Another option is maintain the nation state, but to make it responsive only to the needs of the international economy. This would be a state that would pursue global economic integration at the expense of other domestic objectives. The nineteenth century gold standard provides a historical example of this kind of a state. The collapse of the Argentine convertibility experiment of the 1990s provides a contemporary illustration of its inherent incompatibility with democracy.

Finally, we can downgrade our ambitions with respect to how much international economic integration we can (or should) achieve. So we go for a limited version of globalization, which is what the post-war Bretton Woods regime was about (with its capital controls and limited trade liberalization). It has unfortunately become a victim of its own success. We have forgotten the compromise embedded in that system, and which was the source of its success.

So I maintain that any reform of the international economic system must face up to this trilemma. If we want more globalization, we must either give up some democracy or some national sovereignty. Pretending that we can have all three simultaneously leaves us in an unstable no-man's land.   

Comments

[Cometoqiu]

Hi there, I read your blog on a regular basis. Your story-telling style is witty, keep it up!jelqing

[Calvin Brock]

Many places and centers offer business and trade promotions to both buyers and suppliers. Páginas Amarillas

[Calvin Brock]

prevent global regulation and supervision of financial intermediaries, and render a global lender of last resort a hopeless dream. The malfunctioning of the global financial system is intimately linked with these specific transaction costs. Venapro scam

[Rastia Rigie]

Bank Mandiri Bank Terbaik di Indonesia
Bank Mandiri Bank Terbaik di Indonesia
Promo Bonus 100% Sbobet, Ibcbet dan Casino Online Dalam Rangka HUT BAVETLINE Yang Kedua
Masterbet88 Grand Opening Promo Bonus 50% Sportsbook dan Casino Online

[bathmate]

I every time emailed this web site post page to all my associates, since if like to read it next my links will too.
bathmate
bathmate coupon

[Ipung Xyz]

The article posted was very informative and useful

jaring futsal and jaring golf

[DjNasir]

It is so nicely explained, I really like reading all these quality articles, as that help me understand a lot about world’s economy and to be a successful trader, it is very much obvious that we need to be fully aware of all the stuff around the globe. I am not desperate because I already got ideal source in OctaFX broker, as they provide us with daily market news and analysis report, it is also free of cost, so I don’t need much else after that.

[Bgsubhash]

We experience this Trilema in India regularly.Example GST (General sales tax) one tax for all 29 states. At parliament it faces opposition, at many states this faces opposition as these democratically elected governments do not want to partake their present tax earnings as they do not want cut in their stupid welfare schemes. 29 states, thousands of regulatory discontinuities at the border is a thing to be experienced. Hopefully GST will be cleared shortly by the parliament. Agree with you "If we want more globalization, we must either give up some democracy or some national sovereignty. Pretending that we can have all three simultaneously leaves us in an unstable no-man's land."

[Lara Dsouza]

Thanks for sharong such a wonderful post..!!!

http://www.pillsuppliers.com/bimatoprost

[Lara Dsouza]

Thanks for sharing such a good thought with us. keep on work like this..!!!

http://www.pillsuppliers.com/bimatoprost

[Lara Dsouza]

Thanks for sharing the information. It is really effective post…!!

http://www.pillsuppliers.com/bimatoprost

[Huseyin Cetinel]

https://lastikci724.com
https://kayalarotolastik.com

Lastik Tamiri, Lastikçi, Ataşehir lastikçi, Kadıköy Lastikçi, Maltepe Lastikçi