Oh, where have all the competent forgers gone?

Pity the mafia that is staging what is probably the most significant political trial in modern Turkey’s history – a show trial in which more than three hundred Turkish military officers stand accused of plotting a military coup back in 2003.  Since early 2010, the mafia has produced three different batches of evidence to put the defendants behind bars.  Alas, each batch contains such obvious signs of forgery that they seem rather the handiwork of a bunch of crooked Keystone Kops.  Naturally the only thing that keeps the trial going is the heavy support of the AKP government and its Gulenist allies. 

First, there was a trunk full of documents delivered to a newspaper reporter.  The documents, digital Word files on CDs, described in gory detail preparations for a military coup.  Within days, it became clear that these files had just a small problem: even though they were made to look like they dated from 2003, they referred to future events or entities that did not yet exist. By now, hundreds of such anachronisms and other inconsistencies have been identified in this first batch, leaving no doubt that the documents are the product of a much later hand.

Then, with great fanfare a second batch of digital documents was unearthed from a naval base.  One might have thought the forgers would have become better at their craft with experience.  Apparently not.  The new documents not only repeated the initial mistakes, they compounded them.  Officers were shown on a ship not yet commissioned, on duty in an outfit not yet created, or in meetings they supposedly attended while hundreds of miles away.    

So when a third find was reported, this one a flash disk supposedly found in a retired air force officer’s home, I thought for sure that it wouldn’t contain such inconsistencies and anachronisms .  Indeed, this time forgers tried to be smart and cover for their earlier blunders.  They inserted in the new documents statements to the effect that the coup plotters had made conscious mistakes in their documents to cover their tracks.  (Of course, it was left unclear how such “mistakes” could account for 2009 information finding its way into a 2003 document – but no matter.)   

But incredibly they again slipped up.  In fact, this third find contains some of the worst howlers to date.  One document in which plotters allegedly lay out their desired changes in legislation contains an annex in which the future amended form of the law is cited, down to its precise number and date of adoption two years later! A document supposedly prepared in 2007 contains the scan of a newspaper article from 2009.    

Is it so difficult to find competent forgers?

This would all be funny if hundreds of people were not in jail on the basis of such documents, and if another indictment had not just been accepted by a Turkish court – based on the third batch of fabricated evidence. 

What is equally scandalous is the almost complete lack of coverage in the Turkish media of the facts of this case.  “Independent” media, intimidated by the government, shies away from discussing the problems with the evidence and the evident manipulation by the police and prosecutors.  Pro-government media, including most notably the Gulenist media, act as the propaganda arm of the prosecutors and systematically distort the facts.

And what do the supporters of the prosecution say when confronted with the evidence of fabrication? A common response is that the anachronisms are due to the “updating” by the coup plotters of the original documents.  The trouble with this argument is that the documents show no sign of updating – except for the occasional anachronism.  The names on them belong to officers on duty back in 2003, long since retired.  The dates – both on the files themselves and in the metadata – are also from the earlier years.  It is evident that the true authors of these documents altered the system clock of the computers on which they worked to make it look like they were prepared and last saved in 2003.

At this point, the defenders of the case lose any pretence of coherence.  They say it is up to the defendants to explain why such inconsistencies and anachronisms exist.  I am not kidding.  Here is Bülent Keneş, the editor the Gulenist daily Today’s Zaman.  So if the prosecutors cannot prove their case, the defendants must to do it for them.

Did you say Kafka?  No, this is all too absurd even by that standard.

Comments

[Lena Kong]

Did you check our e-commerce website ? You can now buy your favorite heels straight from our site ! http://www.christianlouboutinsalenet.com/ Christian Louboutin Sale

[backpack union]

Cheap Louis Vuitton Handbags I am so glad to hear that practical activities about water issues, environment friendly agriculture and many other matters will be set.

[Nflfacebook]

Ugg Støvler "Parce que l'initiative du Président Obama est une opportunité historique, sans remettre en cause la légitimité d'une dissuasion nationale indépendante tant que perdurent d'autres arsenaux, la France dira sa disponibilité pour une négociation en vue d'un désarmement nucléaire universel, graduel, négocié et contrôlé". Comme nous l'indiquions sur ce blog en septembre, le PS n'a rien cédé sur la dissuasion nucléaire, à laquelle les écologistes sont viscéralement opposés. Si ce n'est une vague "disponibilité" à discuter du désarmement nucléaire - ce qui est déjà la position de la France.

[Nflfacebook]

Canada Goose La présence de flottes militaires dans l'océan indien ne parvient pas à réduire la piraterie somalienne - à peine à la contenir. Du coup, des initiatives privées voient le jour. On n'en est plus à l'embarquement d'équipes de protection mais à la mise en place d'une flotte de bateaux d'escorte armés.

[D]

UGG Boots Lloyd devrait investir environ 80 millions de dollars pour mettre en place son dispositif qui pourrait entrer en service au deuxième trimestre 2012. La société, dirigée par le canadien Angus Cambell, s'appuie pour la partie navale sur une société basée à Chypre (Dobson Fleet Management) et pour le personnel paramilitaire sur Global Risk Partners.

[Marie Lewis]

American Goose says:

Hopefully the lies and deception of Hizmet have caught up with them. Their witch hunts "sledgehammer" "Ergenekon" and other LABELS, they choose to put on those that oppose them is pure violation of Democracy and freedom of speech. Ironically, Cemaat touts themselves as "tolerant", "peaceful" etc.,
Yet, you show any opposition to this group they will work to try and destroy you.
This group must be stopped in Turkey and throughout the world. They are producing a "Golden Generation" that is a generation of idiots with no free thinking skills.
Sick obsession this group has with a leader that cannot come out to play or leave his compound that he is a prisoner of.
Fetos go home! (if you can)
http://www.gulenpoliticians.blogspot.com
http://www.turkishinvitations.weebly.com

[David Berndt]

I was interested to read about this very unsual topic on forging manuscripts. As someone with an editing service I find that a good proofreading can go a long way towards critiquing forgeries, especially with manuscripts of short length and poor copy editing.

[Xiaoyaoxiao]

Rosetta Stone is a computer program that is designed to allow you to easily learn another language. Though it is primarily made to be used with computers running Microsoft's Windows operating system, there is a way for Ubuntu users to install it as well. This is by installing a program called "WINE" on your Ubuntu computer. Rosetta Stone WINE is a type of emulator that allows Ubuntu to recognize files that are meant for the Windows operating system. Once WINE is installed, Rosetta Stone installs relatively painlessly.

[Aleclihong]

Moncler
Sabàto was born in Rome, Italy. His mother, Yvonne Kabouchy, is a realtor born in Prague (in the former Czechoslovakia), and his father, Antonio Sabàto, Sr., is an Italian actor. His maternal grandfather was a Czech aristocrat, and his maternal grandmother was Jewish and survived the Holocaust.

[Aleclihong]

Sabàto was married to Alicia Tully Jensen from May 16, 1992 to July 1993.[10] He has a son, Jack Antonio (born August 6, 1994), from his relationship with actress Virginia Madsen and a daughter, Mina Bree (born August 29, 2002), with longtime girlfriend Kristin Rossetti Moncler Jackets

[Harold M. taylor]

Thanks for providing such a great article, it was excellent and very informative. as a first time visitor to your blog I am very impressed. I found a lot of informative stuff in your article. Keep it up. Thank you.

[JeffreyWGibbs]

When you tweeted that the amount of tomfoolery in the Balyoz case was unprecedented, you weren't kidding. I'm not sure even the North Koreans would go this far with a straight face. And somehow these people are being extolled as the models for the Muslim World. Why doesn't this stuff at least make the foreign media? Who seem to cover these arrests--whether from Ergenekon, Balyoz, or KCK with a very light touch.

[John William]

the competent forgers? only you!
excessive sweating
hyperhidrosis

[Narguila Peralta]

Excellent post Dani, like always. Nice to be here.
Coches Electricos Precios
Motos Electricas Precios

[GooLuckU]

cool gadgets

[John Hampton]

very nice article
windows 8

[Richardberry1]

Such and informative article.
http://www.salsabil.org

[Mehmet Ali Alhas]

Thanks Good blog Doni!

seo
---
nedir

[Athena Bell]

thanks for all the help in this
buy backlinks
backlink service

[Johnson Bircho]

Probably you were looking at the wrong place as there is plenty of good specialists eager to work and do the best they can just like those behind iPhone 4S Jailbreak

[A Facebook User]

Seo

[D]

Good stuff. Thanks for such an informative article and the extensive explanation, it's been very useful. ryska kvinnor

[Blinicorovi]

interesting article
recycled glass countertops